| A.J. Pollock | Base | 204 | Diamondbacks |
| David Peralta | Base | 149 | Diamondbacks |
| Jake Lamb | Auto - Big League | BLA-JL | Diamondbacks |
| Jake Lamb | Base | 74 | Diamondbacks |
| Ketel Marte | Base | 281 | Diamondbacks |
| Patrick Corbin | Base | 27 | Diamondbacks |
| Paul Goldschmidt | Base | 111 | Diamondbacks |
| Paul Goldschmidt | Base | 303 | Diamondbacks |
| Paul Goldschmidt | Base - Variation | 111 | Diamondbacks |
| Paul Goldschmidt | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-PG | Diamondbacks |
| Paul Goldschmidt | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-PG | Diamondbacks |
| Robbie Ray | Base | 323 | Diamondbacks |
| Steven Souza Jr. | Auto - Big League | BLA-SS | Diamondbacks |
| Steven Souza Jr. | Base | 155 | Diamondbacks |
| Swimming Pool | Base | 356 | Diamondbacks |
| Yasmany Tomas | Base | 283 | Diamondbacks |
| Zack Greinke | Base | 299 | Diamondbacks |
| Zack Greinke | Base | 321 | Diamondbacks |
| A.J. Minter | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-AM | Braves |
| Anibal Sanchez | Base | 152 | Braves |
| Dansby Swanson | Base | 39 | Braves |
| Ender Inciarte | Base | 9 | Braves |
| Ender Inciarte | Base | 305 | Braves |
| Freddie Freeman | Base | 135 | Braves |
| Freddie Freeman | Base | 317 | Braves |
| Freddie Freeman | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-FF | Braves |
| Freddie Freeman | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-FF | Braves |
| Hank Aaron | Base | 331 | Braves |
| John Smoltz | Base | 335 | Braves |
| Julio Teheran | Base | 119 | Braves |
| Luiz Gohara | Base | 260 | Braves |
| Nick Markakis | Base | 133 | Braves |
| Ozzie Albies | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-OA | Braves |
| Ozzie Albies | Base | 48 | Braves |
| Ozzie Albies | Base - Variation | 48 | Braves |
| Rio Ruiz | Base | 84 | Braves |
| Ronald Acuna Jr. | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-RA | Braves |
| Ronald Acuna Jr. | Base | 369 | Braves |
| Sean Newcomb | Base | 49 | Braves |
| Adam Jones | Base | 215 | Orioles |
| Andrew Cashner | Base | 93 | Orioles |
| Austin Hays | Base | 77 | Orioles |
| B&O Warehouse | Base | 364 | Orioles |
| Cal Ripken Jr. | Base | 336 | Orioles |
| Chance Sisco | Base | 165 | Orioles |
| Chris Davis | Base | 158 | Orioles |
| Dylan Bundy | Base | 380 | Orioles |
| Jim Palmer | Base | 340 | Orioles |
| Jonathan Schoop | Base | 81 | Orioles |
| Kevin Gausman | Base | 267 | Orioles |
| Manny Machado | Base | 105 | Orioles |
| Manny Machado | Base - Variation | 105 | Orioles |
| Manny Machado | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-MM | Orioles |
| Manny Machado | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-MM | Orioles |
| Pedro Alvarez | Base | 385 | Orioles |
| Tim Beckham | Auto - Big League | BLA-TB | Orioles |
| Tim Beckham | Base | 259 | Orioles |
| Trey Mancini | Base | 44 | Orioles |
| Zach Britton | Base | 217 | Orioles |
| Andrew Benintendi | Base | 276 | Red Sox |
| Andrew Benintendi | Base - Variation | 276 | Red Sox |
| Chris Sale | Base | 83 | Red Sox |
| Chris Sale | Base | 320 | Red Sox |
| Chris Sale | Base | 324 | Red Sox |
| Chris Sale | Base | 328 | Red Sox |
| Chris Sale | Base | 330 | Red Sox |
| Craig Kimbrel | Base | 130 | Red Sox |
| Craig Kimbrel | Base | 326 | Red Sox |
| Dustin Pedroia | Base | 148 | Red Sox |
| Eduardo Rodriguez | Base | 400 | Red Sox |
| Green Monster | Base | 358 | Red Sox |
| J.D. Martinez | Base | 37 | Red Sox |
| Jackie Bradley Jr. | Base | 280 | Red Sox |
| Mitch Moreland | Base | 395 | Red Sox |
| Mookie Betts | Base | 159 | Red Sox |
| Mookie Betts | Base | 308 | Red Sox |
| Mookie Betts | Base - Variation | 159 | Red Sox |
| Mookie Betts | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-MB | Red Sox |
| Mookie Betts | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-MB | Red Sox |
| Pedro Martinez | Base | 342 | Red Sox |
| Rafael Devers | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-RD | Red Sox |
| Rafael Devers | Base | 250 | Red Sox |
| Rafael Devers | Base - Variation | 250 | Red Sox |
| Rick Porcello | Base | 21 | Red Sox |
| Roger Clemens | Base | 332 | Red Sox |
| Ted Williams | Base | 338 | Red Sox |
| Tzu-Wei Lin | Base | 161 | Red Sox |
| Xander Bogaerts | Base | 134 | Red Sox |
| Addison Russell | Base | 202 | Cubs |
| Albert Almora Jr. | Base | 393 | Cubs |
| Anthony Rizzo | Base | 91 | Cubs |
| Anthony Rizzo | Base - Variation | 91 | Cubs |
| Ben Zobrist | Base | 388 | Cubs |
| Bricks Ivy | Base | 351 | Cubs |
| Ernie Banks | Base | 334 | Cubs |
| Ernie Banks Statue | Base | 357 | Cubs |
| Jason Heyward | Base | 52 | Cubs |
| Javier Baez | Base | 192 | Cubs |
| Jon Lester | Base | 4 | Cubs |
| Jose Quintana | Base | 73 | Cubs |
| Kris Bryant | Auto - Big League | BLA-KB | Cubs |
| Kris Bryant | Base | 300 | Cubs |
| Kris Bryant | Base | 311 | Cubs |
| Kris Bryant | Base - Variation | 300 | Cubs |
| Kris Bryant | Insert - Ministers Of Mash | MI-9 | Cubs |
| Kris Bryant | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-KB | Cubs |
| Kris Bryant | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-KB | Cubs |
| Kyle Schwarber | Base | 197 | Cubs |
| Willson Contreras | Base | 127 | Cubs |
| Avisail Garcia | Auto - Big League | BLA-AG | White Sox |
| Avisail Garcia | Base | 87 | White Sox |
| Avisail Garcia | Base | 316 | White Sox |
| Carson Fulmer | Base | 164 | White Sox |
| Frank Thomas | Auto - Big League | BLA-FT | White Sox |
| Frank Thomas | Base | 344 | White Sox |
| Frank Thomas Statue | Base | 353 | White Sox |
| Jose Abreu | Base | 99 | White Sox |
| Jose Abreu | Base - Variation | 99 | White Sox |
| Jose Abreu | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-JA | White Sox |
| Jose Abreu | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-JA | White Sox |
| Lucas Giolito | Base | 284 | White Sox |
| Nicky Delmonico | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-ND | White Sox |
| Nicky Delmonico | Base | 98 | White Sox |
| Reynaldo Lopez | Base | 179 | White Sox |
| Tim Anderson | Base | 71 | White Sox |
| Tyler Saladino | Base | 189 | White Sox |
| Yoan Moncada | Base | 40 | White Sox |
| Yolmer Sanchez | Base | 195 | White Sox |
| Adam Duvall | Auto - Big League | BLA-AD | Reds |
| Adam Duvall | Base | 220 | Reds |
| Billy Hamilton | Base | 210 | Reds |
| Billy Hamilton | Base | 313 | Reds |
| Homer Bailey | Base | 298 | Reds |
| Joey Votto | Base | 28 | Reds |
| Joey Votto | Base | 311 | Reds |
| Joey Votto | Base - Variation | 28 | Reds |
| Joey Votto | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-JV | Reds |
| Joey Votto | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-JV | Reds |
| Johnny Bench | Base | 347 | Reds |
| Luis Castillo | Base | 236 | Reds |
| Raisel Iglesias | Base | 72 | Reds |
| Scooter Gennett | Base | 33 | Reds |
| Scott Schebler | Base | 61 | Reds |
| Tucker Barnhart | Base | 173 | Reds |
| Andrew Miller | Base | 30 | Indians |
| Carlos Carrasco | Base | 145 | Indians |
| Carlos Carrasco | Base | 322 | Indians |
| Corey Kluber | Base | 290 | Indians |
| Corey Kluber | Base | 320 | Indians |
| Corey Kluber | Base | 322 | Indians |
| Corey Kluber | Base | 324 | Indians |
| Corey Kluber | Base | 330 | Indians |
| Edwin Encarnacion | Base | 68 | Indians |
| Edwin Encarnacion | Base | 312 | Indians |
| Francisco Lindor | Base | 70 | Indians |
| Francisco Lindor | Base - Variation | 70 | Indians |
| Francisco Lindor | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-FL | Indians |
| Francisco Lindor | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-FL | Indians |
| Francisco Mejia | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-FM | Indians |
| Francisco Mejia | Base | 180 | Indians |
| Greg Allen | Base | 279 | Indians |
| Jason Kipnis | Base | 391 | Indians |
| Jose Ramirez | Auto - Big League | BLA-JR | Indians |
| Jose Ramirez | Base | 85 | Indians |
| Jose Ramirez | Base | 308 | Indians |
| Jose Ramirez | Base | 318 | Indians |
| Trevor Bauer | Base | 95 | Indians |
| Yan Gomes | Base | 389 | Indians |
| Carlos Gonzalez | Base | 293 | Rockies |
| Chad Bettis | Base | 253 | Rockies |
| Charlie Blackmon | Base | 117 | Rockies |
| Charlie Blackmon | Base | 303 | Rockies |
| Charlie Blackmon | Base | 305 | Rockies |
| Charlie Blackmon | Base | 315 | Rockies |
| Charlie Blackmon | Base | 317 | Rockies |
| Charlie Blackmon | Base - Variation | 117 | Rockies |
| DJ LeMahieu | Base | 121 | Rockies |
| Gerardo Parra | Base | 218 | Rockies |
| German Marquez | Base | 296 | Rockies |
| Greg Holland | Base | 325 | Rockies |
| Jon Gray | Base | 239 | Rockies |
| Nolan Arenado | Base | 69 | Rockies |
| Nolan Arenado | Base | 301 | Rockies |
| Nolan Arenado | Base | 307 | Rockies |
| Nolan Arenado | Base | 309 | Rockies |
| Nolan Arenado | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-NA | Rockies |
| Nolan Arenado | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-NA | Rockies |
| Trevor Story | Base | 46 | Rockies |
| Dixon Machado | Base | 381 | Tigers |
| James McCann | Base | 271 | Tigers |
| Jordan Zimmermann | Base | 224 | Tigers |
| Jose Iglesias | Base | 270 | Tigers |
| Matt Boyd | Base | 233 | Tigers |
| Michael Fulmer | Base | 174 | Tigers |
| Miguel Cabrera | Base | 238 | Tigers |
| Miguel Cabrera | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-MC | Tigers |
| Miguel Cabrera | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-MC | Tigers |
| Mikie Mahtook | Auto - Big League | BLA-MM | Tigers |
| Mikie Mahtook | Base | 268 | Tigers |
| Nicholas Castellanos | Base | 242 | Tigers |
| Alex Bregman | Base | 287 | Astros |
| Alex Bregman | Base - Variation | 287 | Astros |
| Cameron Maybin | Base | 314 | Astros |
| Carlos Correa | Base | 200 | Astros |
| Carlos Correa | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-CC | Astros |
| Carlos Correa | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-CC | Astros |
| Dallas Keuchel | Base | 196 | Astros |
| George Springer | Base | 252 | Astros |
| George Springer | Base | 304 | Astros |
| Gerrit Cole | Base | 60 | Astros |
| J.D. Davis | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-JD | Astros |
| Jeff Bagwell | Base | 345 | Astros |
| Jose Altuve | Auto - Big League | BLA-JA | Astros |
| Jose Altuve | Base | 104 | Astros |
| Jose Altuve | Base | 304 | Astros |
| Jose Altuve | Base | 306 | Astros |
| Jose Altuve | Base | 314 | Astros |
| Jose Altuve | Base | 316 | Astros |
| Jose Altuve | Base - Variation | 104 | Astros |
| Josh Reddick | Base | 186 | Astros |
| Justin Verlander | Base | 269 | Astros |
| Justin Verlander | Base | 328 | Astros |
| Ken Giles | Base | 86 | Astros |
| Lance McCullers Jr. | Base | 118 | Astros |
| Yuli Gurriel | Base | 286 | Astros |
| Alcides Escobar | Base | 246 | Royals |
| Alex Gordon | Base | 20 | Royals |
| Bo Jackson | Base | 339 | Royals |
| Danny Duffy | Base | 128 | Royals |
| Eric Hosmer | Base | 306 | Royals |
| Eric Hosmer | Base | 316 | Royals |
| Fountains | Base | 352 | Royals |
| George Brett | Base | 337 | Royals |
| Jason Vargas | Base | 322 | Royals |
| Lucas Duda | Base | 176 | Royals |
| Mike Moustakas | Base | 275 | Royals |
| Salvador Perez | Base | 96 | Royals |
| Salvador Perez | Base - Variation | 96 | Royals |
| Salvador Perez | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-SP | Royals |
| Salvador Perez | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-SP | Royals |
| Whit Merrifield | Auto - Big League | BLA-WM | Royals |
| Whit Merrifield | Base | 12 | Royals |
| Whit Merrifield | Base | 314 | Royals |
| Albert Pujols | Base | 178 | Angels |
| Andrelton Simmons | Base | 209 | Angels |
| Garrett Richards | Base | 75 | Angels |
| Ian Kinsler | Base | 51 | Angels |
| Justin Upton | Base | 120 | Angels |
| Keynan Middleton | Base | 377 | Angels |
| Kole Calhoun | Base | 206 | Angels |
| Mike Trout | Auto - Big League | BLA-MT | Angels |
| Mike Trout | Base | 150 | Angels |
| Mike Trout | Base | 312 | Angels |
| Mike Trout | Base | 318 | Angels |
| Mike Trout | Base - Variation | 150 | Angels |
| Mike Trout | Insert - Ministers Of Mash | MI-10 | Angels |
| Mike Trout | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-MT | Angels |
| Mike Trout | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-MT | Angels |
| Parker Bridwell | Base | 247 | Angels |
| Ricky Nolasco | Base | 229 | Angels |
| Shohei Ohtani | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-SO | Angels |
| Shohei Ohtani | Base | 141 | Angels |
| Zack Cozart | Base | 295 | Angels |
| Alex Wood | Base | 125 | Dodgers |
| Chase Utley | Base | 392 | Dodgers |
| Chris Taylor | Base | 205 | Dodgers |
| Clayton Kershaw | Base | 50 | Dodgers |
| Clayton Kershaw | Base | 319 | Dodgers |
| Clayton Kershaw | Base | 321 | Dodgers |
| Clayton Kershaw | Base | 329 | Dodgers |
| Clayton Kershaw | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-CK | Dodgers |
| Clayton Kershaw | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-CK | Dodgers |
| Cody Bellinger | Base | 15 | Dodgers |
| Cody Bellinger | Base | 301 | Dodgers |
| Cody Bellinger | Insert - Ministers Of Mash | MI-3 | Dodgers |
| Corey Seager | Base | 80 | Dodgers |
| Corey Seager | Base - Variation | 80 | Dodgers |
| Justin Turner | Auto - Big League | BLA-JT | Dodgers |
| Justin Turner | Base | 241 | Dodgers |
| Justin Turner | Base | 315 | Dodgers |
| Kenley Jansen | Base | 256 | Dodgers |
| Kenley Jansen | Base | 325 | Dodgers |
| Kenley Jansen | Base - Variation | 256 | Dodgers |
| Logan Forsythe | Base | 288 | Dodgers |
| Matt Kemp | Base | 187 | Dodgers |
| Sandy Koufax | Base | 350 | Dodgers |
| Walker Buehler | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-WB | Dodgers |
| Walker Buehler | Base | 116 | Dodgers |
| Yasiel Puig | Base | 36 | Dodgers |
| Brad Ziegler | Base | 78 | Marlins |
| Brian Anderson | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-BA | Marlins |
| Brian Anderson | Base | 291 | Marlins |
| Dee Gordon | Base | 305 | Marlins |
| Dee Gordon | Base | 313 | Marlins |
| Dillon Peters | Base | 214 | Marlins |
| Giancarlo Stanton | Base | 301 | Marlins |
| Giancarlo Stanton | Base | 303 | Marlins |
| Giancarlo Stanton | Base | 309 | Marlins |
| Giancarlo Stanton | Base | 317 | Marlins |
| Giancarlo Stanton | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-GS | Marlins |
| J.T. Realmuto | Base | 387 | Marlins |
| Jose Urena | Base | 66 | Marlins |
| Justin Bour | Auto - Big League | BLA-JB | Marlins |
| Justin Bour | Base | 264 | Marlins |
| Marcell Ozuna | Base | 309 | Marlins |
| Sandy Alcantara | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-SA | Marlins |
| Sandy Alcantara | Base | 190 | Marlins |
| Starlin Castro | Base | 129 | Marlins |
| Bernie's Dugout | Base | 363 | Brewers |
| Brandon Woodruff | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-BW | Brewers |
| Brandon Woodruff | Base | 136 | Brewers |
| Christian Yelich | Base | 29 | Brewers |
| Corey Knebel | Base | 146 | Brewers |
| Corey Knebel | Base | 325 | Brewers |
| Domingo Santana | Base | 261 | Brewers |
| Eric Thames | Base | 17 | Brewers |
| Jonathan Villar | Base | 79 | Brewers |
| Keon Broxton | Auto - Big League | BLA-KBR | Brewers |
| Keon Broxton | Base | 243 | Brewers |
| Lorenzo Cain | Base | 184 | Brewers |
| Orlando Arcia | Base | 188 | Brewers |
| Ryan Braun | Base | 82 | Brewers |
| Ryan Braun | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-RB | Brewers |
| Ryan Braun | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-RB | Brewers |
| Travis Shaw | Base | 181 | Brewers |
| Zach Davies | Base | 6 | Brewers |
| Zach Davies | Base | 321 | Brewers |
| Brian Dozier | Base | 23 | Twins |
| Byron Buxton | Base | 38 | Twins |
| Byron Buxton | Base - Variation | 38 | Twins |
| Byron Buxton | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-BB | Twins |
| Byron Buxton | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-BB | Twins |
| Eddie Rosario | Base | 100 | Twins |
| Ervin Santana | Base | 175 | Twins |
| Ervin Santana | Base | 328 | Twins |
| Felix Jorge | Base | 102 | Twins |
| Jake Odorizzi | Base | 157 | Twins |
| Jorge Polanco | Base | 123 | Twins |
| Jose Berrios | Base | 292 | Twins |
| Logan Morrison | Base | 163 | Twins |
| Max Kepler | Auto - Big League | BLA-MK | Twins |
| Max Kepler | Base | 26 | Twins |
| Miguel Sano | Base | 198 | Twins |
| Miguel Sano | Insert - Ministers Of Mash | MI-4 | Twins |
| Minnie and Paul | Base | 355 | Twins |
| Zack Granite | Base | 97 | Twins |
| Amed Rosario | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-AR | Mets |
| Amed Rosario | Base | 63 | Mets |
| Amed Rosario | Base - Variation | 63 | Mets |
| Brandon Nimmo | Base | 124 | Mets |
| Darryl Strawberry | Auto - Big League | BLA-DS | Mets |
| Dominic Smith | Base | 34 | Mets |
| Home Run Apple | Base | 354 | Mets |
| Jacob deGrom | Base | 219 | Mets |
| Jacob deGrom | Base | 323 | Mets |
| Jacob deGrom | Base - Variation | 219 | Mets |
| Jason Vargas | Base | 41 | Mets |
| Jeurys Familia | Base | 5 | Mets |
| Juan Lagares | Base | 160 | Mets |
| Matt Harvey | Base | 65 | Mets |
| Noah Syndergaard | Auto - Big League | BLA-NS | Mets |
| Noah Syndergaard | Base | 282 | Mets |
| Noah Syndergaard | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-NS | Mets |
| Noah Syndergaard | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-NS | Mets |
| Robert Gsellman | Base | 397 | Mets |
| Todd Frazier | Base | 379 | Mets |
| Tomas Nido | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-TN | Mets |
| Travis d'Arnaud | Base | 45 | Mets |
| Yoenis Cespedes | Base | 109 | Mets |
| Aaron Judge | Base | 1 | Yankees |
| Aaron Judge | Base | 302 | Yankees |
| Aaron Judge | Base | 304 | Yankees |
| Aaron Judge | Base | 310 | Yankees |
| Aaron Judge | Base | 312 | Yankees |
| Aaron Judge | Base | 318 | Yankees |
| Aaron Judge | Base - Variation | 1 | Yankees |
| Aaron Judge | Insert - Ministers Of Mash | MI-1 | Yankees |
| Aaron Judge | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-AJ | Yankees |
| Aaron Judge | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-AJ | Yankees |
| Alex Rodriguez | Base | 343 | Yankees |
| Aroldis Chapman | Base | 76 | Yankees |
| Brandon Drury | Base | 53 | Yankees |
| Brett Gardner | Base | 384 | Yankees |
| Clint Frazier | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-CF | Yankees |
| Clint Frazier | Base | 112 | Yankees |
| Derek Jeter | Auto - Big League | BLA-DJ | Yankees |
| Didi Gregorius | Base | 90 | Yankees |
| Gary Sanchez | Auto - Big League | BLA-GS | Yankees |
| Gary Sanchez | Base | 162 | Yankees |
| Gary Sanchez | Base - Variation | 162 | Yankees |
| Giancarlo Stanton | Base | 171 | Yankees |
| Giancarlo Stanton | Insert - Ministers Of Mash | MI-8 | Yankees |
| Giancarlo Stanton | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-GS | Yankees |
| Gleyber Torres | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-GT | Yankees |
| Gleyber Torres | Base | 368 | Yankees |
| Luis Severino | Base | 2 | Yankees |
| Luis Severino | Base | 320 | Yankees |
| Luis Severino | Base | 330 | Yankees |
| Mariano Rivera | Base | 349 | Yankees |
| Masahiro Tanaka | Base | 228 | Yankees |
| Miguel Andujar | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-MA | Yankees |
| Miguel Andujar | Base | 166 | Yankees |
| Monument Park | Base | 365 | Yankees |
| Ronald Torreyes | Auto - Big League | BLA-RT | Yankees |
| Sonny Gray | Base | 263 | Yankees |
| Tyler Austin | Base | 383 | Yankees |
| Tyler Wade | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-TW | Yankees |
| Whitey Ford | Base | 333 | Yankees |
| Andrew Triggs | Base | 398 | Athletics |
| Daniel Mengden | Base | 24 | Athletics |
| Jed Lowrie | Base | 108 | Athletics |
| Jed Lowrie | Base | 308 | Athletics |
| Jharel Cotton | Base | 262 | Athletics |
| Khris Davis | Base | 58 | Athletics |
| Khris Davis | Base | 302 | Athletics |
| Khris Davis | Base | 310 | Athletics |
| Khris Davis | Insert - Ministers Of Mash | MI-2 | Athletics |
| Khris Davis | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-KD | Athletics |
| Khris Davis | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-KD | Athletics |
| Marcus Semien | Base | 32 | Athletics |
| Matt Chapman | Auto - Big League | BLA-MC | Athletics |
| Matt Chapman | Base | 154 | Athletics |
| Matt Olson | Auto - Big League | BLA-MO | Athletics |
| Matt Olson | Base | 19 | Athletics |
| Matt Olson | Base - Variation | 19 | Athletics |
| Paul Blackburn | Base | 103 | Athletics |
| Rickey Henderson | Base | 346 | Athletics |
| Sean Manaea | Base | 216 | Athletics |
| Stephen Piscotty | Base | 265 | Athletics |
| Aaron Altherr | Auto - Big League | BLA-AA | Phillies |
| Aaron Altherr | Base | 274 | Phillies |
| Aaron Nola | Base | 101 | Phillies |
| Carlos Santana | Base | 183 | Phillies |
| Cesar Hernandez | Base | 386 | Phillies |
| Hector Neris | Base | 42 | Phillies |
| J.P. Crawford | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-JC | Phillies |
| J.P. Crawford | Base | 3 | Phillies |
| Jake Arrieta | Base | 106 | Phillies |
| Jorge Alfaro | Base | 285 | Phillies |
| Maikel Franco | Base | 193 | Phillies |
| Nick Williams | Base | 297 | Phillies |
| Odubel Herrera | Base | 10 | Phillies |
| Odubel Herrera | Base | 307 | Phillies |
| Phillie Phanatic | Auto - Big League | BLA-PP | Phillies |
| Rhys Hoskins | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-RH | Phillies |
| Rhys Hoskins | Base | 113 | Phillies |
| Rhys Hoskins | Base - Variation | 113 | Phillies |
| Rhys Hoskins | Insert - Ministers Of Mash | MI-5 | Phillies |
| Rhys Hoskins | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-RH | Phillies |
| Rhys Hoskins | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-RH | Phillies |
| Scott Kingery | Base | 372 | Phillies |
| Vince Velasquez | Base | 227 | Phillies |
| Andrew McCutchen | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-AM | Pirates |
| Andrew McCutchen | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-AM | Pirates |
| Chad Kuhl | Base | 399 | Pirates |
| Corey Dickerson | Base | 11 | Pirates |
| Felipe Vazquez | Base | 258 | Pirates |
| Gerrit Cole | Base | 327 | Pirates |
| Gregory Polanco | Base | 35 | Pirates |
| Honus Wagner | Base | 341 | Pirates |
| Honus Wagner Statue | Base | 361 | Pirates |
| Ivan Nova | Base | 234 | Pirates |
| Jameson Taillon | Base | 59 | Pirates |
| Jordy Mercer | Base | 43 | Pirates |
| Josh Bell | Base | 143 | Pirates |
| Josh Harrison | Auto - Big League | BLA-JH | Pirates |
| Starling Marte | Base | 273 | Pirates |
| Tyler Glasnow | Base | 207 | Pirates |
| Austin Hedges | Base | 249 | Padres |
| Brad Hand | Base | 272 | Padres |
| Christian Villanueva | Base | 371 | Padres |
| Clayton Richard | Base | 257 | Padres |
| Cory Spangenberg | Auto - Big League | BLA-CSP | Padres |
| Dinelson Lamet | Base | 14 | Padres |
| Eric Hosmer | Base | 92 | Padres |
| Franchy Cordero | Base | 375 | Padres |
| Hunter Renfroe | Base | 31 | Padres |
| Luis Perdomo | Base | 245 | Padres |
| Manny Margot | Base | 18 | Padres |
| Travis Jankowski | Base | 221 | Padres |
| Wil Myers | Base | 56 | Padres |
| Wil Myers | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-WM | Padres |
| Wil Myers | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-WM | Padres |
| Andrew McCutchen | Base | 153 | Giants |
| Brandon Belt | Auto - Big League | BLA-BP | Giants |
| Brandon Belt | Base | 151 | Giants |
| Brandon Crawford | Base | 194 | Giants |
| Buster Posey | Base | 203 | Giants |
| Buster Posey | Base - Variation | 203 | Giants |
| Buster Posey | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-BP | Giants |
| Buster Posey | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-BP | Giants |
| Evan Longoria | Base | 89 | Giants |
| Hunter Pence | Base | 142 | Giants |
| Jeff Samardzija | Base | 47 | Giants |
| Jeff Samardzija | Base | 327 | Giants |
| Joe Panik | Base | 222 | Giants |
| Johnny Cueto | Base | 138 | Giants |
| McCovey Cove | Base | 360 | Giants |
| Miguel Gomez | Base | 225 | Giants |
| Ty Blach | Base | 147 | Giants |
| Ben Gamel | Auto - Big League | BLA-BG | Mariners |
| Ben Gamel | Base | 237 | Mariners |
| Dee Gordon | Base | 172 | Mariners |
| Edwin Diaz | Base | 376 | Mariners |
| Felix Hernandez | Base | 8 | Mariners |
| Ichiro | Base | 226 | Mariners |
| James Paxton | Base | 137 | Mariners |
| Jean Segura | Base | 94 | Mariners |
| Kyle Seager | Base | 277 | Mariners |
| Mike Leake | Base | 156 | Mariners |
| Mike Zunino | Base | 223 | Mariners |
| Mitch Haniger | Base | 54 | Mariners |
| Nelson Cruz | Base | 144 | Mariners |
| Nelson Cruz | Base | 310 | Mariners |
| Nelson Cruz | Insert - Ministers Of Mash | MI-7 | Mariners |
| Robinson Cano | Base | 62 | Mariners |
| Robinson Cano | Base - Variation | 62 | Mariners |
| Robinson Cano | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-RC | Mariners |
| Robinson Cano | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-RC | Mariners |
| Ryon Healy | Base | 266 | Mariners |
| Carlos Martinez | Base | 57 | Cardinals |
| Carlos Martinez | Base | 327 | Cardinals |
| Dexter Fowler | Base | 115 | Cardinals |
| Harrison Bader | Base | 373 | Cardinals |
| Jack Flaherty | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-JF | Cardinals |
| Jack Flaherty | Base | 167 | Cardinals |
| Jedd Gyorko | Base | 390 | Cardinals |
| Jordan Hicks | Base | 366 | Cardinals |
| Jose Martinez | Base | 378 | Cardinals |
| Luke Weaver | Base | 177 | Cardinals |
| Marcell Ozuna | Base | 114 | Cardinals |
| Matt Carpenter | Base | 278 | Cardinals |
| Matt Carpenter | Base | 311 | Cardinals |
| Paul DeJong | Base | 199 | Cardinals |
| Stan Musial Statue | Base | 362 | Cardinals |
| Tommy Pham | Base | 107 | Cardinals |
| Tyler O'Neill | Base | 367 | Cardinals |
| Yadier Molina | Base | 254 | Cardinals |
| Yadier Molina | Base - Variation | 254 | Cardinals |
| Yadier Molina | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-YM | Cardinals |
| Yadier Molina | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-YM | Cardinals |
| Adeiny Hechavarria | Base | 382 | Rays |
| Alex Colome | Base | 64 | Rays |
| Alex Colome | Base | 326 | Rays |
| Blake Snell | Base | 16 | Rays |
| Brad Miller | Base | 248 | Rays |
| C.J. Cron | Base | 7 | Rays |
| Chris Archer | Base | 13 | Rays |
| Chris Archer | Base | 324 | Rays |
| Evan Longoria | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-EL | Rays |
| Evan Longoria | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-EL | Rays |
| Kevin Kiermaier | Base | 132 | Rays |
| Touch Tank | Base | 359 | Rays |
| Adrian Beltre | Base | 230 | Rangers |
| Adrian Beltre | Base - Variation | 230 | Rangers |
| Adrian Beltre | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-AB | Rangers |
| Adrian Beltre | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-AB | Rangers |
| Bartolo Colon | Base | 235 | Rangers |
| Cole Hamels | Base | 201 | Rangers |
| Elvis Andrus | Base | 212 | Rangers |
| Elvis Andrus | Base | 306 | Rangers |
| Joey Gallo | Auto - Big League | BLA-JG | Rangers |
| Joey Gallo | Base | 140 | Rangers |
| Joey Gallo | Base | 302 | Rangers |
| Jurickson Profar | Base | 396 | Rangers |
| Martin Perez | Base | 122 | Rangers |
| Matt Moore | Base | 294 | Rangers |
| Nolan Ryan | Base | 348 | Rangers |
| Nomar Mazara | Base | 168 | Rangers |
| Ronald Guzman | Base | 374 | Rangers |
| Rougned Odor | Base | 289 | Rangers |
| Shin-Soo Choo | Base | 185 | Rangers |
| J.A. Happ | Base | 244 | Blue Jays |
| Josh Donaldson | Base | 131 | Blue Jays |
| Josh Donaldson | Base - Variation | 131 | Blue Jays |
| Justin Smoak | Auto - Big League | BLA-JS | Blue Jays |
| Justin Smoak | Base | 255 | Blue Jays |
| Kendrys Morales | Base | 211 | Blue Jays |
| Kevin Pillar | Base | 55 | Blue Jays |
| Lourdes Gurriel Jr. | Base | 370 | Blue Jays |
| Marco Estrada | Base | 232 | Blue Jays |
| Marcus Stroman | Base | 231 | Blue Jays |
| Marcus Stroman | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-MS | Blue Jays |
| Marcus Stroman | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-MS | Blue Jays |
| Richard Urena | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-RU | Blue Jays |
| Richard Urena | Base | 110 | Blue Jays |
| Roberto Osuna | Base | 126 | Blue Jays |
| Roberto Osuna | Base | 326 | Blue Jays |
| Russell Martin | Base | 88 | Blue Jays |
| Yangervis Solarte | Base | 208 | Blue Jays |
| Andrew Stevenson | Base | 67 | Nationals |
| Anthony Rendon | Base | 169 | Nationals |
| Bryce Harper | Base | 25 | Nationals |
| Bryce Harper | Insert - Ministers Of Mash | MI-6 | Nationals |
| Bryce Harper | Insert - Star Caricature Originals | SC-BH | Nationals |
| Bryce Harper | Insert - Star Caricature Reproductions | SCR-BH | Nationals |
| Daniel Murphy | Base | 170 | Nationals |
| Daniel Murphy | Base | 307 | Nationals |
| Daniel Murphy | Base | 315 | Nationals |
| Erick Fedde | Base | 191 | Nationals |
| George Washington | Auto - Big League | BLA-GW | Nationals |
| Mark Reynolds | Base | 22 | Nationals |
| Max Scherzer | Base | 240 | Nationals |
| Max Scherzer | Base | 319 | Nationals |
| Max Scherzer | Base | 323 | Nationals |
| Max Scherzer | Base | 329 | Nationals |
| Michael Taylor | Base | 394 | Nationals |
| Ryan Zimmerman | Base | 139 | Nationals |
| Sean Doolittle | Auto - Big League | BLA-SD | Nationals |
| Stephen Strasburg | Base | 251 | Nationals |
| Stephen Strasburg | Base | 319 | Nationals |
| Stephen Strasburg | Base | 329 | Nationals |
| Theodore Roosevelt | Auto - Big League | BLA-TR | Nationals |
| Trea Turner | Base | 182 | Nationals |
| Trea Turner | Base | 313 | Nationals |
| Victor Robles | Auto - Rookie Republic | RR-VR | Nationals |
| Victor Robles | Base | 213 | Nationals |
